Rush Limbaugh Doctors Audio to Slander Mark Levine

March 24, 2010

“A Glittering Jewel of Colossal Ignorance”
Mark Levine in Rush Limbaugh's eyes
Rush Limbaugh depicts Mark Levine in the most unflattering way he can.

Yesterday, Rush Limbaugh called me a “glittering jewel.”
Actually he called me a “glittering jewel of colossal ignorance.”
But I no more took his quotation about me out of context just now than he took mine.

First, the Rush clip, in its full context:

Now, what I actually said:

See a difference?

OK, it may be hard to spot in the unedited clips. So here’s the same thing tightly focused.

Rush playing me on air (without mentioning he intentionally tampered with the audio to remove a crucial sentence):

What I actually said:

Let me spell it out.

Rush claims I said:

“If you heard Rush Limbaugh today, he specifically compared Barack Obama to Hitler. This is not rhetoric that’s coming out of nowhere. People understand the tea party activists are drawing Hitler mustaches on Obama. They’re doing it for a reason”

What I actually said was this:

“David, if you heard Rush Limbaugh today, he specifically compared Barack Obama to Hitler. He said in fact that Bart Stupak was the Neville Chamberlain to Barack Obama’s Hitler. This is not rhetoric that’s coming out of nowhere. People understand the tea party activists are drawing Hitler mustaches on Obama. They’re doing it for a reason”

Why do you think Rush removed that sentence that specifically showed where he compared Obama to Hitler then went on a long rant saying, “Adolf Hitler was not mentioned on this program yesterday” ?

Maybe it’s because he mentioned the Obama/Hitler comparison on the program the day before yesterday and thinks his dittoheads are too stupid to remember two days ago?

You see, Rush made the Obama/Hitler comparison on Monday:

“That executive order, totally laughable, Stupak just wanted his “notice me” moment. Stupak is no different than Neville Chamberlain, came back with that little letter from Hitler.”

Then on Wednesday, Rush says, with a wink and a nod to himself, “we never said Hitler yesterday (Tuesday) when he knows full well he made the comment Monday! He calls it: a total lie!

So Rush, while I stand by my condemnation of what you said on Monday, I made a mistake in thinking it was said on Tuesday. Now will you apologize for implying you never made the comparison and for tampering with my audio (without even a clearly heard “audio click”) to take out the sentence where I specify exactly what you said?

Rush owes me an apology, a retraction, and the full playing of the accurate clip on air. He also should tell his listeners the truth: that he made the odious Obama/Hitler comparison, even if he made it one day earlier. And it’s certainly not the only time Rush has compared President Obama to Hitler.

Rush Limbaugh doctored the audio and transcript of what I said yesterday to delete the one, short key sentence where I detail Rush’s comparison of Obama to Hitler. Rush wanted his dittohead listeners to think I was making it all up.

Stung by my forceful comments on MSNBC condemning his comparison of President Obama to Adolf Hitler, Rush strongly suggested yesterday he would never, ever do that. Perhaps his defensiveness would have been a bit more persuasive had he not begun right away again with a comparison of the President’s health care plan to that of the Nazis:

Now, as far as this Hitler business, one of the first things the National Socialist Party did was try to nationalize health care.

Think about the logic here: first, Rush makes the dubious claim that the Nazis “tried” to nationalize health care. Is it true? Well, I do seem to recall the Nazis murdered the handicapped, tried to sterilize homosexuals, fired all the Jewish doctors, euthanized the infirm, and practiced ghastly experiments, designed more to exquisitely torture their victim than to determine anything of medical significance. That’s what Nazi Health Care is infamous for.

First of all, I want to ensure Rush — and all of the wacko dittoheads that believe every word he said as if he knew something of academic value rather than having flunked out of Southeast Missouri University in his first year — that President Obama’s plan has none of the Nazi elements I quoted above.

But what if it’s true? What if the Third Reich actually did provide good heterosexual “Aryans” with decent health care? Does this make it an awful idea? Let’s assume it’s true, for the sake of argument, and see how far we can go with the same logic.

What else did the Nazis do?  They greatly expanded their military spending. And, you know what, Republicans also believe in greatly expanding our military spending. Aha!

Now am I calling Republicans Nazis? Oh no, not me. I’m only saying, using wacko-Rush-logic, that Republican policies are similar to the Nazis, that they “head in that direction”. That’s all I’m saying. Just don’t blame me if some of my supporters misconstrue the angry rhetoric and draw Hitler mustaches on Mitch McConnell…

Why pick on just Republicans? Let’s take the same Rush-logic one dramatic step further. The great Fascist leader of Italy Benito Mussolini was quite famous for making the trains run on time. By Rush-logic, anyone who believes in on-time trains is a Fascist! Watch out for Amtrak workers!!! And is it any coincidence our Vice-President Joe Biden is a big fan of trains? Hmmm? I’m not saying… I’m just saying…

But the real crime in Rush’s rush to trash me comes from Rush’s intentional tampering of the video where I made the claim on MSNBC that Rush is doing his best to enrage the public with his phony Obama/Hitler comparisons.

The full unedited transcript of the clip, obtained from Rush’s own website, is below in bold, with my comments in brackets.

Now, as far as this Hitler business, one of the first things the National Socialist Party did was try to nationalize health care. I mean, facts are facts: The president is a socialist. The number ought to be much higher than 67%. And we got the New York Times saying so today. We’ve got what’s-her-face, Sebelius, saying so today. We got John Dingell: “Control the people.” Worse than socialist. Well, Shuster was mentioning all that to one of his guests, a guy by the name of Mark Levine, who is an attorney (not Mark “Le-vin,” Mark “Le-veen”) and Shuster said, “Why is it fair to pin this on Limbaugh?”

LEVINE: If you heard Rush Limbaugh today, he specifically compared Barack Obama to Hitler. (sic) This is not rhetoric that’s coming out of nowhere. People understand the tea party activists are drawing Hitler mustaches on Obama. They’re doing it for a reason. There are a lot of mostly angry, white, Southern, male, fundamentalist Christians who are very angry.

[Note the (sic).  (Sic), for those of us who know grammar, means emphatically that this is what was actually said. You put it in a transcription so that readers know the transcriber did not make a typographical error, as in "He said, 'You was (sic) a friend of mine.'"  This lets the reader know that the speaker was using bad grammar and not the person transcribing it. Here Rush slanders me by saying inaccurately that I never said the sentence in between the two he mentioned.  He should have put in an ellipsis (...) which shows when someone has removed content.  But that would let his readers know he tampered with the audio.  They would have rejected the silly notion that I couldn't detail when Rush compared Obama to Hitler, when, in fact, I specifically called it out.]

[Oh, and for the record, I happen to be a Southern white male.  But not angry.  :-) ]

SHUSTER. Oh.

[Actually, this wasn’t Shuster but the Republican guest. Oh well.  This is Rush’s transcript.  Guess I should say “(sic)” after Shuster.

LEVINE: They see their power being taken away, they see blacks in power, they see a woman Speaker of the House, they see a gay man as head of the Financial Services Committee, and they’re worried. The irony is this bill will actually help most of the people, they just don’t know it.

RUSH: A blooming idiot, a glittering jewel of colossal ignorance. Somebody help me: Did we even mention Adolf Hitler yesterday? It’s a total lie. Adolf Hitler was not mentioned on this program yesterday. We didn’t even talk about any of these Hitler videos yesterday, right? The word “Hitler” was not uttered on this program. And here comes the cliche: “Mostly angry, white, Southern, male, fundamentalist Christians. Very angry, see their power being taken away.” This is what passes for learned analysis. Do these guys get together after the show and do a circle you-know-what, ever? Or are they doing that underneath the desk during the show? What a bunch of blooming idiots, and this guy is an attorney, and it says here he has a radio show of his own? That’s probably the problem. Nobody listens to it and he’s ticked off about that.

No one should be surprised that Rush regularly tampers with videos and says he things he knows to be untrue and then fakes disingenuousness when challenged.  “Who me?  I said nothing about Hitler yesterday. I said it the day before yesterday!”  Just as no one should be surprised that neither the New York Times nor Health Secretary Katherine Sibelius called the President a socialist, even though Rush says so.

One more thing: when confronted with the Harris Poll showing 24% of Republicans think Obama is the Anti-Christ and 45% think he’s Muslim, Rush said:

“Well, I don’t know wh– (laughs) Anti-Christ and uh, and uh Muslims. I don’t know where they’re getting that, because that’s not a, uh (pause) part of the program. And I haven’t really made that one of our topics here. But uh–”

How come Rush didn’t say that’s not, uh, a, ummm TRUE?

Do you really need to ask?

And a final thought to discuss among yourselves, class:  Do you think Rush regularly tampers with video without telling his naive listeners?

Share

10 Comments

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

  • Richard Rhodes July 18, 2010 5:33 pm

    You no what we need in this country. Far less people like you who try to slander people all the time. I have no idea why fox let’s you on the air ever. It is one thing to be far and balanced, it is another thing to let a little disgusting bastard like you to mouth off all the time. You really need to shut your mouth and stop slandering people. One day it could get you into real trouble.

  • randy April 11, 2010 5:33 pm

    i think we should abolish the Democratic Party. They have done nothing to promote black people and everything to hinder them. I challenge you to give me one piece of legislation that the Democratic party introduced into congress to promote black people. In fact the democratic party was started to expand slavery. You are either a Democrat by deception or a racist.
    PROVE ME WRONG, you can’t. All legislation to help black people was introduced by Republicans. In fact the Republican party was formed to stop the Democrats from inflicting so much pain to the blacks. So lets abolish the hypocritical , i mean the moron democratic party.
    LOOK IT UP

  • greg April 8, 2010 8:17 pm

    Read it. Believe it.

  • Al April 8, 2010 11:01 am

    Again,as usual Rush is right. Amazing
    with all his “higher” edgamaction Levine still comes across as a fool!!

  • Mark Levine March 31, 2010 7:50 am

    Of course he compared Obama to Hitler, on both Monday and Wednesday (the very day I criticized him). Listen to the tape. Read the transcripts on both days. Check out the video. As it happened, Rush didn’t compare Obama to Hitler on Tuesday, he doctored my audio to remove my specific example, and Rush then pretended to his listeners (who apparently have very short memories) that he didn’t do it all. Hilarious, if it weren’t so serious, because it shows what idiots Rush knows his regular audience to be.

    If you disagree with the Administration’s policies, SAY SO!

    But if you use the n-word or compare Obama to Hitler or claim that he’s born outside the USA or is a Muslim or that he’s the Anti-Christ, or even that he’s a socialist (which he clearly is not), or claim the country is headed toward tyranny or Armageddon or any other B.S., then you are not part of the “loyal opposition.” You are disloyal and unpatriotic, and you are lying to Americans, either to promote violence or to trick ignorant people into voting for your party. (I’m not saying you did that, B.G., I’m talking generically.)

    And I condemn those on the Left who do it as well (although such tactics are rarely supported by mainstream liberals). By this tactic, everyone that disagrees with you is Hitler or Stalin, and all we have left in our polity is anger, fear, and violence.

    If you disagree with the health care law, give specific reasons why. But if all you can do is call your opponents Hitler, you will have shown that you are ignorant, dangerous, and hypocritical (because you’re not even intelligent enough to formulate a logical argument as to why you disagree with something). Leave it to Rush Limbaugh to rely on demagoguery rather than logical analysis. As a college flunkee disc jockey, he’s much better at anger, fear, and hypocrisy than he is at reading legislation and using reason to oppose it. And he calls me a “glittering jewel of colossal idiocy”?

    Finally, I never said all Southerners felt this way or that all tea partiers were from the South. I happen to be a Southern white male myself. My point is that most tea partiers are white and most are male, many are Southern and many are fundamentalist Christian, and their opposition to Obama is based on prejudices common among many angry white Southern male fundamentalist Christians (though certainly not all of them). Most of the raw anger and emotion and violence has extremely little to do with health care reform.

  • Mark Levine March 26, 2010 3:51 pm

    Thank you to Media Matters for writing about the incident here:
    http://mediamatters.org/blog/201003250057

  • Frank Gahl March 24, 2010 6:09 pm

    I listened to that Rush show and he did NOT mention Hitler. You ought to listen for yourself next time. Then you wouldn’t look like a idiot. I mean Im just saying you should get it right… Cheers!

  • B.G. March 24, 2010 1:51 pm

    It would be helpful for you to actually listen to Rush Limbaugh before you spread untruths about him. He never compared Obama to Hitler. He has suggested that Obama is moving the country to socialism. Proof is ramming an unpopular Health Care Bill down the throats of disapproving Americans of all ethnic varieties. He also used bribes and strong arm tactics as well as Lie to Americans about the contacts of this pile of dung.

    By the way Levine don’t mistake anger for passion. People are passionate about these isssues and not just angry white Southerners. I’m from California and there are many like me who are concerned with this Administrations policies. Stop being disingenuous and start waking up to the truth.

    B.G.

  • Frank Gahl March 24, 2010 1:42 pm

    I listened to Rush’s show and he never mentioned Hitler. Did you lie or are you just incompetant? You soooo funny. Peace

  • Frank Gahl March 24, 2010 1:32 pm

    Mark, I listened to all of Rush’s show and he never mentioned Hitler. Why don’t you actually listen to the show before makingt yourself look BAD? BTW why don’t you look at what the German National Socialist actually did. I’d tell you but you need to start doing your own work instead of just listening to what others say. Peace.